Visa’s Agentic Commerce Benchmark found that 22 AI models made suitable shopping decisions in 57.2% of test runs, leaving a 42.8% failure rate. The assessment tested whether agents could identify products that met a buyer’s requirements—or decline to buy when none did. Models that gathered more buyer details through conversation performed better, but even the strongest model fell short of a perfect score. The findings concern shopping decisions, not a direct test of payment execution. The results add to questions about how autonomous purchasing could operate at scale. Visa’s consumer research found limited trust in AI systems making payments, while its survey of acquirers identified liability and compliance concerns. Disputed agent transactions currently fall under existing card-not-present rules unless an authenticated, tokenized flow shifts liability. Payment-industry work on agent identity and standards is advancing, but a unified approach to disputes over non-fraud purchases by autonomous agents has not been established.

